In summer of 2026, MTC held the second iteration of our Big Book Summer by reading Karl Marx’s Capital Vol. I. Below are informal reflections written by some of the reading group participants.

Farah Bakaari:

My favorite part of reading Capital Vol. I with our extended MTC community this summer was reading Capital Vol. I with our extended MTC community this summer. It is almost a cliché to note that Marxist spaces can be bombastic, exclusionary, not to mention male dominated and altogether tiresome. Or at least this has been my experience, having henceforth made all my attempts of reading Marx in the rarified halls of wealthy American schools. Once in college, a classmate I knew from union organizing crowd—a white boy from Chicago with big, freckled face and even bigger sense of self— invited me to some such reading group by saying, “we could really use someone like you, someone who can bring in the perspective of the Global South.” I didn’t see what else I could contribute having already fulfilled the role in which I had been cast: the proletariat of History. I told my classmates I had plans to wash my hair that day. So, I just want to sincerely thank everyone who participated in the Capital reading group this summer and contributed to the creation of a thinking environment that felt rigorous precisely because it was open, inviting, and collegial.

Reading, I tell my students, is a form of labor. It is intense and embodied. And reading Capital did feel at times rather laborious—the long footnotes, the asides into labor history that no longer feel familiar or relevant, the endless arbitrary math which to the numerically challenged felt like being asked to read ancient Greek, the free indirect discourse which seems essential to his style of argumentation. But the text itself never felt stale, there was always dynamism at its core, because its object of analysis, capitalism, is a dynamic process. I found the text’s painstaking reminder that struggle between labor and capital is central to capitalism to be the most profound aspect of Capital. Yes, capitalism always wants to extend the working day, always in quest of depreciating labor, but labor always pushes back. It is a life and death struggle. There is a sense of freedom, if that is even the right word, in the experience of demystification that reading Capital facilitates.

I write this journal entry in Berkeley, CA, on the day in which across the Bay Bridge Anthropic made its initial public offering (IPO) which valued the company—a vampiric monstrosity built on the en masse pillaging of all human knowledge and wreaks havoc on the planet and its resources, which also has never turned a profit—at $1.5 trillion, the largest IPO in history. No better example of the fact that capitalism is awfully interested in things appearing a certain way—most of all in capital appearing natural, desirable, and inevitable. But it is none of these things. We can and we must imagine the end of capitalism because we might in fact be living in the end of the world. “Between equal rights, force decides,” Marx writes. May the force be with us.

*

James Perla:

Reading Capital with Mid Theory Collective offered a wonderful opportunity to learn from fellow scholars, who, as MTC’s mission statement goes, find themselves in the middle of things. The reading group, in many ways, redirected that feeling of middleness toward a historical awareness that grounds, in the sense of absorbing excess electricity, the shock of presentism through a method that targets capital as a diachronic and lasting problem in which we are in the midst.

In this regard, the sustained engagement with Capital underscores the necessity of historically materialist informed literary study. One moment that crystallizes this, for me, is Marx’s discussion of the characterological dimensions of capital. An individual becomes a capitalist by internalizing capital’s logic. This helps sharpen the critique of capitalism to target not solely ethical arguments, but also material ones. The individual who becomes a capitalist is not necessarily a malicious individual, but an individual who personifies the logic of capital and thereby becomes “the conscious bearer” of its circulation and translation into value; therefore, the individual merely “function(s) as a capitalist, i.e., as capital personified and endowed with a consciousness and will” (Marx, 1990, 254). This opens interpretive avenues for how literary works can diagnose and intervene in this subjective identification with capital.

From this perspective, capitalists are standard bearers, functionaries, and avatars of capital whose self-making hinges on a poesis in the capitalist mold, a process of becoming homo economicus through the normalization and internalization of consent to the capitalist mode of production. In this way, for cultural production to be anti-capitalist, it must directly target the construction of subjectivity that compels fealty to identify with capital at the level of character, and by extension, personhood.

During one of our meetings, I referenced Charles Johnson’s short story “Exchange Value,” which also features in Lauren Berlant’s influential work Cruel Optimism. A prolific African American novelist who holds a PhD in philosophy, Johnson famously wrote Karl Marx into his 1982 novel Oxherding Tale. His engagement with Marx, however, extends across his oeuvre, as Linda Seltzer details in a 2001 article in The Massachusetts Review about Johnson’s short story. In brief, “Exchange Value” operationalizes Marx’s insight about “capital personified” through a portrayal of how its titular concept gets expressed in its characters’ words and deeds, their consciousness and will. In this way, Johnson’s short story might serve as a useful literary example for pedagogical purposes to read alongside the first chapter of Capital, in particular, as it illustrates key concepts such as use value, exchange value, and commodity fetishism. I hope this reading journal reflects the collaborative spirit of MTC’s reading group to read and learn together. Immersing oneself in Marx is no middling feat. Thanks, MTC!

*

Adora Svitak:

I had been scared to approach Capital Vol. 1 for quite some time because of the feeling that I did not look or sound like a real Marx head. This archetype existed in my head as the type of guy I’d met in seminars: looming gently over me, wearing an Oxford shirt or blue-collar cosplay, all shades of white, slate-gray, and navy, waxing eloquent about sheaves of wheat and theory of value. I (small woman, interested in gender, sexuality, and Marx’s catty takedowns of all his contemporaries) knew there was something in Capital Vol. 1 and not just for the bros. (Lifting weights is good for everyone but the gym can be alienating; in a similar vein, I was scared to read Capital alone!) When MTC announced the Big Book Summer I got the book at Dog Eared Books in San Francisco and read the first ten pages in Dolores Park with a socialist smugness, regarding the happy families of AI engineers and shirtless polycules playing spikeball like that guy in the party hat in the “They Don’t Know” meme (sorry, sometimes language fails). The wind whipped the pages and I found myself opening Incognito windows on my phone to look up questions like “what is commodity fetish” and, ten minutes later, “what is commodity fetish” again.

The first Zoom meeting allayed my primary fear (that we would be lined up and cold-called to answer questions like “what is commodity fetish” and expelled on the spot for failure) and did much more — made me feel like it’s OK, and wonderful, for scholars much further along than me to have questions about Marx, wrestle with the applications of his theories to current crises, and continue to analyze the rhetorical and political work being done in this text. Having to devote the fullness of my attention to 940 pages (and failing whenever census data was involved) was an incredible exercise and one that gained so much meaning from doing it with comrades. In the final meeting, I noted that I was really interested by how much Marx writes about intimate life as a site of harm, and the implicit ideologies of gender and family — that are clearly in flux and being unsettled by the demands of capitalist commodification — from the insults to propriety posed by mine work for women, to crowded and squalid family life in hovels where people sleep a dozen to a room. Peter Coviello made a point about how there is so much scholarship in gender and sexuality studies about urban geography and what happens when wage laborers move into cities, and how some (e.g., Whitman) are excited by the sexual possibilities that are opened up by urban space. I think I’ll close by sharing one of my favorite quotes that I believe was from Peter in that session: “Look at work and see theft. If you get nothing else but this from Capital, you’re winning.” (Finally: I might remember “what is commodity fetish?”!)

*

*

Michael Druffel:

This was my second time in a reading group devoted to Marx’s Capital, Vol 1. And as helpful as this group was, I’m afraid I’m going to need a third and a fourth reading group to keep learning. I still don’t feel comfortable with my understanding of the commodity fetish. Is it that people are tricked into believing that commodities are imbued with agency? And that this mistaken belief in agency causes the workers to mistrust their own power… while forgiving capitalists for price gouging and theft? Or is it that collective belief in agential commodities has truly brought commodities alive, and now we really have to confront commodities that can dictate our lives? And by extension, how does Marx theorize agency in Capital?

Similarly, I have questions about the difference between labor-power and labor. Is labor-power the price that capitalists pay for labor, which is always cheaper than the value that labor imparts? Is labor the activity of working? Do labor-power and labor map onto Marx’s exchange value/use value distinction? If so, how?

And these content questions don’t include my questions about Marx’s method and style. Why does Marx spend so much time writing about money when it seems fairly obvious that money is a representative of value? What is the relation between Marx’s theory and the nitty-gritty stats and historical events that he records? Why does Marx wait till the very end of Vol 1 to discuss primitive accumulation–the original crimes that birthed capitalism? Why does Marx start with the commodity if the book is about capital? Wait… is the book primarily about capital? Is it class struggle? History? Philosophy? Something else?

The one thing I don’t have questions about is the reading group itself. This was a valuable and thought-provoking experience. I am lucky that there’s a community working to understand Marx and by extension our world and ourselves. I’m lucky that the staff puts in all this time and energy to organize it. There’s no question about that.

But I do have one more question: when are we doing the Vol 2 and 3 reading groups?

*

*

Brice Ezell:

The word “portable” seems ill-suited to Volume One of Karl Marx’s Capital, especially the new Princeton University Press edition that I annotated throughout my time with the Big Book Summer squad. Clocking it at just shy of three pounds, my copy of Capital was typically the heaviest thing I carried in my briefcase throughout the summer of 2026. Yet by the time I’d wrapped up my first reading of Volume One, “portable” felt like one of the most apt words I could use for Marx’s dense and dazzling account of capitalism’s machinations.

Prior to actually reading Capital, my encounters with Marx could best be summarized by a great line spoken by a pretentious college student in Whit Stillman’s Metropolitan, who tells a woman that he doesn’t read novels because he “prefer[s] good literary criticism. That way you get both the novelists’ ideas as well as the critics’ thinking.” When I read the likes of Terry Eagleton and Raymond Williams in my undergraduate years, Marx came into my consciousness via osmosis; however, I never actually braved the source itself. Now that I have, the things that intrigued me about his thought’s presence in those writers have manifested for me as a portable heuristic for understanding the world around me. Sure, I like many would struggle to perfectly map out the materialist metaphysics of the commodity articulated across the first 150 or so pages of Volume One, but Marx’s overall account of capitalism’s relentless pursuit of surplus value at the expense of the worker has become a mental tool in the toolbox that I turn to frequently now. How could I not, living in late capitalism?

The portability of Marx’s theorizing proved helpful right away. I ordered a copy of Frederic Jameson’s Representing Capital from Verso after finishing Volume One, the commentary I chose to be my “reflection text” on the weighty tome of Big Book Summer 2026. Starting in summer 2025 I began noticing that many of the books I ordered online came stamped in their final pages with a marker bearing information about the print-on-demand service that supplied the copy of the text. The version of Roberto Bolaño’s novel The Third Reich came imprinted with a print date that was the very same date I ordered it. I didn’t know anything about the print-on-demand industry upon this first discovery, but since then I’ve kept a keen eye out for this type of printing service, which many accuse of producing an inferior product at the sake of profitability. So, when Representing Capital arrived in the mail, I flipped to the back of the book and, sure enough, there was the telltale marker of the print-on-demand service. Knowing what I know now because of Volume One, I now feel more equipped to research the material conditions of these kinds of publications, especially because the chapter that most struck me – the grand theory of the machine – gives us the roadmap for understanding the machines that run our world today, including those used by leftist publishing houses.

*

Trevor Aleo:

For Sale: Console Table. Gently-Used.

David Harvey rasped through my car speakers as I clicked on my left blinker and pulled into the long driveway. His lectures on Marx’s Capital Volume 1—sandwiched between full-volume blasts of Olivia Rodrigo’s “the cure”—were the official soundtrack of my summer. As I hopped out of the driver’s seat, the audio switched to my headphones.

“A commodity appears, at first sight, a very trivial thing, and easily understood. Its analysis shows that it is, in reality, a very queer thing, abounding in metaphysical subtleties and theological niceties…”

I shut my door and scanned the seller’s yard. Their house was a large white colonial with a landscaper’s truck at the curb and a Tesla charging in the garage. After spending all morning pulling up weeds in my backyard, their manicured lawn taunted me—an embarrassing reminder that I had fully assimilated into suburban dad life.

The dark brown console table my wife had spotted on Facebook Marketplace sat on their newly paved driveway, awaiting potential buyers. The afternoon sun was less generous than the staged photo they had posted, which had clearly benefited from a well-placed fern and some performatively highbrow coffee table books. The top of the table was pockmarked and a section was faded, as though only half of it caught the sunlight that crept into their foyer. Its legs were in worse shape, scratched and caressed by a dog or cat to the point where it looked like their fur was engrained in the wood—an archive of domestic routine.

My mind drifted back to Marx. I crouched down, checking under the apron for a maker’s mark or a craftsman’s stamp, but found only bare, unvarnished oak. Despite the damage, the craftsmanship was undeniable. It was a beautifully made piece.

I pulled out my phone and tapped the Facebook Messenger button.

“I’m here. Table is in rough shape though,” I typed. “Most I can do is $100.” Three dots in a bubble floated up and then disappeared. I looked around and stared at my phone impatiently. Were they not home? They said 2:30.

My phone buzzed. “Can’t come out. On a work call. $200 is the lowest I’ll go. Sorry!”

“Thanks anyway,” I responded. Sighing, I slipped my phone back into my pocket, slouched into my driver’s seat, and turned the ignition. Harvey’s voice returned through my speakers.

“…the relations connecting the labour of one individual with that of the rest appear, not as direct social relations between individuals at work, but as what they really are, material relations between persons and social relations between things.”

My phone buzzed one last time on the console.

“Nice meeting you!”

I turned up Harvey’s lecture and slowly backed out of the driveway.

*

Olivia Stowell:

While I have read Marx in excerpts before, this was my first time tackling Capital, Vol. 1 as a whole. Something about the experience of reading Capital made me feel like an undergraduate again (in the best way), seeking out online reading guides and listening to David Harvey’s lectures to sift through and sense-make my experience of reading. I am also not usually an audiobook person, but I found that it helped to infuse bite-sized chunks of Capital into my daily routine—most often by listening to either an audiobook version or the YouTube uploads of the Harvey lectures while I was lifting at the gym or driving around town running errands. While I’m not sure that listening to Capital necessarily improved my comprehension, I do think living alongside Marx’s words reoriented my awareness of everyday life, seeing all the objects and relations around me through Marx-goggles. It functionally transformed my workout experience into a theory bro meets gym bro version of the They Don’t Know meme, every deadlift an iteration of They Don’t Know I’m Listening To Capital Volume 1, Part 3: The Production of Absolute Surplus-Value Right Now.

*

Matthew Beeber:

Is Marx’s Capital, aged roughly one and a half centuries, still relevant today? It’s not a particularly approachable text, feeling at times laborious in its recitations of historical data that are difficult to apply to today’s world. It offers a theory of capitalism bounded by time and space (Manchester-style industrial production around the mid-1800s), with actors and stakes that do not map easily onto today’s perceived sites of political struggle. Making matters worse, the text is engaged not in describing how capitalism is (or was) actually practiced but in assaying—diligently and on their own terms—the assumptions put forward by classical political economists of the time, an often disorienting approach to argumentation as we find many of his adversaries’ positions unfamiliar a hundred and sixty years later.

Yet Mid Theory’s recent Capital reading group felt like a success to me, not because we found ways to apply Marx’s theory productively to questions of AI or rising fascism in 2026—although we did do this—but because the process of reading it, the process of grappling with its method in conversation with others (perhaps especially its more arduous stretches), produced the outcome that good theory should: a changed way of thinking the world around us. (This was the case for me at least, along with several others I spoke to.) The fact that this reordering of thought could occur—when we knew the talking points already, when many of us had read the book before, when capitalism looks different for us than it did for Marx—speaks to the enduring relevance of the book, and to the continued value in convening conversations around it.

*

Further Readings Suggested by Group Participants:

Jameson on conspiracy (it must have been The Geopolitical Aesthetic)

Giovanni Arrighi – mentioned generally, one of Pete’s faves

Melinda Cooper: Family Values

Madeleine Baker, Make Your Own Job: How the Entrepreneurial Work Ethic Exhausted America

Critique of Black Reason – Achille Mbembe

Marx and Literature, Raymond Williams

Marx’s 18th Brumaire!

Collected volume of Marx that Pete said is probably floating around online? This was mentioned as a follow-up in the chat:

Surveys of Exile: Political Writings , Marx, Verso

Silvia Federici: Caliban and the Witch

Beverley Best: Automatic Fetish

Joshua Clover, Riot Strike Riot

Lisa Gitelman: Paper Knowledge

Joanne McNeil: Wrong Way

Jakko Kemper: “Generative AI, Everyday Aesthetic Production, and the Imperial Mode of Living”

Charles Wright Mills: White Collar: The American Middle Classes

Julian Posada: Platform Extractivism

Leigh Claire La Berge: Wages Against Artwork

Annie McClanahan: Beneath the Wage

Cedric Robinson: Black Marxism

Finally, the MTC crew will like to thank all of our Big Book Summer participants. Special thanks to our reading group facilitator Matthew Beeber as well as our scholarly guests, Peter Coviello and Sarah Brouillette.


After each MTC reading group, we ask our participants to contribute to our collective reading journal, an informal and necessarily incomplete record of our thinking together. You can find our upcoming reading groups here, and if you will like to lead a reading group for us, please get in touch at editorial@mid-theory.com

Lastly, if you’d like a Capital shirt to commemorate Big Book Summer and to support our good friend and comrade, Adam, you can buy a special edition he made for MTC directly on his website!


Sign up for our monthly newsletter!

We promise not to spam you! We’ll probably forget this task.

The latest